Can You Refreeze Uncrustables? Learn How to Store and Thaw

Can You Refreeze Uncrustables? Learn How to Store and Thaw

Can you refreeze Uncrustables and still savor their original goodness? From safety tips to quality preservation, learn how to make the most of these convenient treats.

Disclosure: This Page May Contain Affiliate Links, Which May Earn Me A Commission, With No Additional Cost To You. Each Of These Links Are Referenced With The Asterisk Symbol * Next To It, At All Places It Is Posted.

When you’re in need of a quick snack during a busy day, easy-to-eat options like Uncrustables are a real lifesaver. It is popular choice for busy individuals looking for a delicious and easy snack. 

But what if you find yourself with leftover Uncrustables that you’d like to refreeze? Can you refreeze Uncrustables if needed?

 We’ll explore the guidelines, safety considerations, and FAQs surrounding this topic.

Join me on a journey through the art of freezing and unfreezing these delightful sandwiches. We will  uncover the secrets to preserving their flavor, texture, and above all, your satisfaction. 

Get ready to unravel the mystery of if you can refreeze Uncrustables. Ready? Let’s dig in! 

Get New Recipes Every Week Directly in your Inbox!

What Are Uncrustables?

Smucker’s Uncrustables are a type of  pre-packaged ready-to-eat sandwiches known for its convenience. They typically consist of fillings like classic peanut butter and jelly enclosed within a soft bread pocket.

The unique aspect of Uncrustables is that the the crusts are removed and the edges of the bread are sealed. These crustless sandwiches are easy to eat without creating any mess. 

These handy snacks are often favored for their portability and quick preparation. While they may not be the healthiest option, they are convenient and tasty.

This makes them a popular choice for quick snacks or meals. It is a hassle-free quick breakfast or convenient snack option.

You can also make your own homemade Uncrustables sandwiches using a sandwich cutter and sealer*.

Should You Refrigerate Or Freeze Uncrustables? 

Uncrustables are typically found in the frozen section of  grocery stores. They are meant to be stored in the freezer until you’re ready to enjoy them or till its expiration date or best-by date. Keeping them frozen helps maintain their quality and freshness. 

It is not recommended to store Smuckers’ Uncrustables in the refrigerator. This will dry out the bread. 

However, you can thaw them in the fridge for up to 24h.

Always follow the storage instructions on the packaging for the best results.

Can You Refreeze Uncrustables? 

It’s not advisable to refreeze Uncrustables due to potential texture changes. However, it’s not a safety concern to do so. 

When you refreeze them, there’s a chance of formation of ice crystals within the sandwich. These ice crystals can affect the texture of the bread.

uncrustables packets outside the box

Uncrustables can turn soggy when the are thawed for the second time. Refreezing will also cause freezer burn on the Uncrustables.

This is why consuming your Uncrustables shortly after thawing is recommended.

Refrain from returning them to the freezer for a second freeze. While they remain edible, their taste and texture might suffer. 

Can You Refreeze Homemade Uncrustables

Short answer is – no! Homemade Uncrustables face the same issues as store-bought Uncrustables when it comes to refreezing. 

Refreezing them can cause the same texture change as attempting to refreeze your store-bought ones. So, is not recommended.

Once you’ve made them, it’s best to consume them after thawing without going through the process of refreezing.  

To make the most of your homemade Uncrustables, try to plan your portions and thaw only what you intend to eat.

Proper Storage of Uncrustables

To ensure the best quality and safety of Uncrustables, proper storage is key. Here’s how to store them correctly:

Freezer Storage

Uncrustables are found in the freezer aisle of grocery stores. They should remain frozen until you’re ready to enjoy them.

If you buy them frozen, keep them in your freezer until you’re ready to eat. Frozen storage maintains their optimal taste and texture. It is the best long-term storage option.

uncrustables stacked up on a white plate

Refrigerator Storage

If you plan to eat Uncrustables within a day, you can thaw them in the refrigerator. Place them in the fridge the night before, and they should be ready to eat the next day.

Refrigeration helps preserve their freshness for a short period.

Avoid Room Temperature

Avoid leaving Uncrustables at room temperature for more than an hour. This can lead to spoilage and bacterial growth, affecting their taste and safety. Keep it at room temperature only if you intend to eat it soon!

Remember, The shelf life of uncrustables will gradually decrease whether you thaw Uncrustables in or outside the fridge. So, for a longer shelf life, keeping it frozen if you do not intend to eat it extends its storage life. 

Similarly. if you plan to freeze homemade Uncrustable sandwiches,  wrap in plastic.  Then put it in a freezer bag or airtight container before putting it in the freezer.

How To Make And Store Homemade Uncrustables

Although they are super convenient and delicious, store-bought Uncrustables are not the healthiest. But you can make a healthier version at home.

You even have the option to make it vegan or gluten-free!

Uncrustables are super easy to make. It take hardly a few minutes and a handful of ingredients to prepare.

To make homemade Uncrustables, you will need these ingredients:

  • Whole grain bread or white bread
  • Fillings of your choice (peanut butter & jelly, peanut butter & honey, Nutella, etc.)
  • Sandwich sealer* or cookie cutter* & fork (to recreate what a sandwich sealer does)
uncrustables packets outside the box

Here are step-by-step instructions for making Uncrustables at home:

  • Briefly warm the bread in the microwave for 5 seconds.
  • Place slices of bread on a cutting board and cut the bread with a cookie cutter.
  • Add the fillings and put another piece of cut bread on top. Make sure to leave some space around the edges. This ensures that the filling doesn’t come out when you seal the little sandwiches..
  • Seal the crust by crimping the edges of the bread together using a fork.

You can serve them right away or store them in the freezer for up to 3 months. Put them in a freezer-safe bag and remove as much air as possible to prevent ice crystals from forming.

You may even wrap each individual Uncrustable in plastic wrap to ensure maximum freshness. Then put them in a freezer-safe bag.

Uncrustables Storage Tips

Here are a couple of suggestions to make your Uncrustables last longer:

  • Always double-check the expiration date on the packaging to ensure you’re starting with a fresh product.
  • If the packaging happens to tear, make sure you’re using clean and dry storage materials to maintain the sandwiches’ quality.
  • When it’s time to thaw, opt for a clean and dry kitchen counter or pantry as your designated spot.
  • Whether they’re store-bought or homemade, thaw your Uncrustables in their original packaging or the same storage container you initially used.
  • Keep them away from high temperatures and any humid spots to maintain their best taste.

How long should Uncrustable stay out of the Fridge/Freezer?

It’s advised to avoid keeping Uncrustables outside the fridge or freezer for more than 2 hours. 

If Uncrustables or any food products are left at room temperature for an extended period , they can become a breeding ground for those not-so-friendly bacteria. This can cause foodborne illness such as food poisoning.

uncrustables packets outside the box

And hey, if your room feels like a sauna and hits over 90°F (32°C), that safe window shrinks to just 1 hour.

It is best to consume the unrefrigerated Uncrustables within the 2-hour window.

If they have been left out for longer, it’s wise to play it safe. Avoid consuming them to prevent any food poisoning.

How Long Do Uncrustables Last In Lunchboxes?

Uncrustables can stay in your lunchbox for approximately 4 to 6 hours, as long as the temperature inside the lunchbox stays at 40°F (4°C) or lower. 

It’s a good idea to use an insulated lunchbox for school lunches.  Pop in an ice pack* to help maintain that cool environment. This prevents any unwelcome bacteria from crashing the party. 

However, if your lunchbox ends up in a hotter spot like a warm classroom or under the sun’s gaze, your safe window shrinks to about 2 to 3 hours. 

To ensure maximum freshness of your Uncrustables, consider packing them right before you head out in the morning. Enjoy them within the suggested time range.

How To Thaw Frozen Uncrustables? 

Thawing frozen Uncrustable sandwich is a breeze! Here’s how:

Room Temperature Method

A great way to thaw the Uncrustables is to leave it to thaw on the kitchen counter. Thaw at room temperature for about 30 to 60 minutes.

This allows the bread and filling to thaw and reach a palatable texture.  

However, Uncrustables should not be kept at room temperature for a long time. Keep an eye on it and don’t leave it out for more than 1-2 hours to ensure food safety.

Once thawed, Uncrustables sandwiches may be refrigerated for up to 24 hours.

Refrigerator Method

Another popular method is to thaw it in the refrigerator. For a controlled thaw, place the frozen Uncrustable in the refrigerator the night before you plan to eat it.

It usually takes about 4 to 6 hours, or even overnight. This method can cause the bread to become dry.

uncrustables stacked up on a white plate

Avoid using the warm water, microwave or toaster to thaw Uncrustables. This can lead to uneven thawing and affect the texture.

Microwaving can also cause the filling can become very hot and pose a safety hazard.  

What Is The Best Way To Eat Uncrustables?

According to the Smucker’s website, the best way to eat these pre-made sandwiches is by thawing them for 30-60 minutes at room temperature. This allows the filling to become soft and the bread to reach a pleasant texture.  

You can refrigerate the thawed Uncrustables for up to 24 hours. For best flavor, eat them within 6-8 hours of thawing

You can also thaw it in the fridge the night  before for a ready-to-eat snack.  

Avoid microwaving, as it can make the bread too soggy or the filling too hot. It is also recommended not to use air fryer or toaster to thaw Uncrustables

Once thawed, unwrap and indulge in the convenient and delicious treat.

Their shelf span will gradually decrease whether you thaw Uncrustables in or outside the fridge. So, keeping it frozen if you do not intend to eat it extends its storage life. 

How To Tell If Uncrustables Has Gone Bad?

Determining if Uncrustables have gone bad is crucial for your health and enjoyment. Here’s how to spot the signs of spoilage:

  • Unpleasant Odor: If you notice an unusual, sour, or foul smell coming from the Uncrustable, it’s a sure sign that it has spoiled.
  • Texture Changes: If the bread is soggy, or if the fillings have an odd consistency.  If it is slimy or discolored, the Uncrustable is likely no longer safe to eat.
  • Mold Growth: Any visible mold on the bread or fillings is a clear sign of spoilage. Do not consume if you see mold.
  • Unusual Color: If the colors of the bread or fillings appear significantly different from their usual appearance, it’s best to discard the Uncrustable.
  • Unpleasant Taste: If the Uncrustable tastes strange, has an off-flavor, or is bland, it might have gone bad.

If you notice any of these signs, it’s safer to err on the side of caution and not consume the Uncrustable.

Homemade Uncrustables made with whole wheat bread, strawberry jam or any other fruit jelly, and natural peanut butter might go bad faster because it has fewer preservatives than factory-made Uncrustables.

Commonly Asked Questions

Are Uncrustables Vegan?

Uncrustables from Smuckers are not vegan. But homemade uncrustables can be made vegan based on the ingredients used.

What are the different flavors of Uncrustables?

Smucker’s offers a variety of flavors, including grape jelly and strawberry jelly sandwiches. The other flavors are honey spread, and chocolate hazelnut spread. They even have a “reduced sugar” option for those watching their sugar intake.

Can you eat frozen Uncrustables?

Absolutely, you can eat frozen Uncrustables. However, it’s worth noting that their taste and texture would differ from the thawed ones. These frozen sandwichesare meant to be thawed before consumption.

How many Uncrustables come In a box?

Currently, there are three sizes on the market here in the U.S. Depending on your location, you can find Uncrustables® in boxes of four, ten, or eighteen.


Get New Recipes Every Week Directly in your Inbox!

Found this Useful??

Let me know in the comment section and share your feedback!
Don’t forget to share it with your friends and family!!

If you found this post useful, PIN the Image below to Check it Out Later!

Join Sugar Spice Community:

Facebook Group | Pinterest | Instagram | YouTube

Looking for more recipes? Sign up for our Sugar Spice newsletter and our YouTube Channel for weekly videos. Also rate, comment and share this article!

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links, which may earn me a commission, with no additional cost to you. Each of these links are referenced with the asterisk symbol * next to it, at all places it is posted.

About the Author

akshita and mihdun of sugar spice n everything nice

Hi! Akshita & Midhun here! Welcome to our blog where we show simple yet awesome recipes for your cravings.

Akshita being allergic to egg, we are committed to providing egg-free recipes along with some vegan friendly options. Read more about us here!

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Get something delicious for your inbox! Sign up for FREE recipes

cupcakes kept in a row
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top